The First Christmas—Kevin Costner’s Gritty Nativity Film Hopes to Bring the Birth of Jesus Back to Reality

A raw, historically grounded Christmas special that appears to be worth our time

Costner’s new ABC special, The First Christmas, takes the Nativity story out of the sparkly yard art and drops it back into the harsh world where it actually happened. According to The Christian Post, the production trades sentimental gloss for realism, giving viewers a look at the political tension, fear, poverty, and oppression surrounding Mary and Joseph’s journey.

A Reverent Lens a Gritty Nativity

The Post reports—rather than portraying the holy couple as serene icons—the special shows them as frightened, exhausted teenagers carrying the weight of a divine calling in a world stacked against them. Roman brutality, social shame, the danger of Herod’s paranoia—Costner’s narration gives room for all of it. Dramatic reenactments pull viewers into the uncertainty that marked their every step toward Bethlehem.

Even with the grit, the special leans into the faithfulness of God. The project highlights the weight and wonder of Christ’s birth, pairing Costner’s narration with commentary from Christian scholars who help anchor the story in Scripture and history. The result is a Nativity that feels both deeply human and spiritually grounded.

When to Watch

The First Christmas airs on ABC, Tuesday, December 9, 2025, at 8:00 PM EST.

It streams the following day on Disney+ and Hulu.

Look For Our Review

We’re always hopeful when filmmakers attempt to honor the Scripture, so we’ll be watching with you. Soon after, you can expect a full Red Sky review and some light theological analysis to break down where the special shines, where it stretches, and how it engages with the biblical record. 

“But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son, born of woman, born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons.” (Galatians 4:4–5)

Amazon Best-Selling Author Pastor Greg Locke just launched his new book. Titled, The King Killers By PASTOR GREG LOCKE. When God places this prophetic sword in your hand, you will know—you were born to be a spiritual king killer. Grab your Book copy now on Amazon.com